SAN FRANCISCO (KCBS) — California’s only publicly elected public defender and his office provide legal representation for over 25,000 people that have been charged with a crime but cannot afford to private legal counsel.

Public Defender Jeff Adachi addresses the criticism that he’s picking on the San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) when he makes their scandals very public as opposed to keeping them between the two departments.

KCBS In Depth with SF Public Defender Jeff Adachi:

Last year’s incident where the department’s crime lab technician was skimming drugs was compounded by the alleged illegal searches by the department of a suspect at the Henry Hotel on 6th Street in the SOMA district.

The 22-year veteran of the criminal justice system said the searches caught on video were done without a search warrant and violated suspects’ constitutional rights.

“Part of my job is to ensure that constitutional rights of people accused of crime are respected,” he said.

According to Adachi 68 police officers had misconduct records or criminal histories hidden from the defense.

The department’s interim police chief Jeffery Godown has accused Adachi of trying to embarrass the police by calling press conferences on these alleged scandals, but Adachi said police had already lied about what happened in the police search video. He added that they gave the department’s public information officer prior notice and shared copies of the questionable video evidence for their review.

“It’s important for people to see this because most people don’t think that this happens,” he said in reference to corruption. “I understand that the chief was upset and that I should not have said anything publicly, but don’t we have a right to know what our police department is doing?” Adachi questioned rhetorically.

Adachi does take Chief Godown at face value that each case will be investigated one by one, but questions whether he is in the best position to investigate misconduct by a police department he oversees. “I do think there is a culture within the SFPD of not respecting the rights of citizens,” Adachi boldly stated. 80 cases have been dismissed by the district attorney due to alleged misconduct. Adachi expects this number to grow to at least the hundreds.

As a private citizen, Adachi has become a vocal proponent of aggressive pension reform for San Francisco government workers. Last November his Proposition B failed at the polls partly because it included medical insurance cuts.

Right now the city is spending $357 million just on retirement pensions alone,” he said noting that the result of what he considers to be a misuse of funds is basic services being cut, and people being laid off.

But he now has three more pension reform proposals that include a higher retirement age, greater employee contributions, and pension caps.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Wire services may have contributed to this report.)

Comments (2)
  1. Come on says:

    Oh for god sakes. You don’t need a search warrant for every type of search! Adachi, you know this and you’re playing it up. Probation search, parole search, consent search, protective sweep, etc.

    Cases get dropped EVERY SINGLE DAY for a large variety of reasons. Tuesday morning, 15+ cases dropped, guaranteed. Happens every day in SF courts. A cop can do everything right, and stll get a case dropped. SF doesn’t care about justice unless it’s prosecuting its cops. Nobody gets convicted in SF.

    Adachi, you’re playing that interview. “Drug dealers often go to jail. They may get probation on the first time, but not after that.” BS. Dealers get drug diversion multiple times before probation. Then probation multiple times before prison. Don’t church it up. Your office does a good job, and like minded judges help. It is what it is.

  2. orchitraz says:


    San Francisco has had big problems with corruption for over a hundred years, currently some of the police are abusing the overtime system and conducting illegal raids for their own gain (among other things) and deny it if you wish but you are ignorant if you do! You sound like you are either the spouse of a somewhat corrupt cop or you are one yourself. You have no idea what it’s like on the other side do you? You have no idea what you are saying when you make it out like SFPD are doing the best they can, and are all totally honest folk… All cops in SF should be mandated to go to psychotherapy and to spend quality time with their families… Police have a multitude of opportunities to take advantage of those they come in contact with, we need to do a lot to take away those opportunities and make sure cops are doing their jobs and aren’t just the other side of the cop/robber coin…

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Watch & Listen LIVE