Brown Halts Construction Of New San Quentin Death Row

SAN QUENTIN (KCBS/AP) — Gov. Jerry Brown on Thursday scrapped plans for a $356 million housing addition to death row at San Quentin State Prison, saying the state cannot justify the expense at a time of massive cuts to essential services.

“It would be unconscionable to earmark $356 million for a new and improved death row while making severe cuts to education and programs that serve the most vulnerable among us,” the Democratic governor said in a statement, noting that the project would have cost the state an estimated $28.5 million annually in debt service.

KCBS’ Barbara Taylor Reports:

Plans for the death row complex were approved in 2003 by former Gov. Gray Davis and continued to be developed under Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. The complex was designed to house 1,152 inmates, allowing California’s condemned population to grow. The state currently has fewer than 700 inmates awaiting death sentences.

But critics called the project a waste of money and said the proposed construction site on the eastern edge of San Quentin could be put to better use. Some proposed transforming the land into a transit hub that would provide a service to the region while generating money for the cash-strapped state.

Assemblyman Jared Huffman, a San Rafael Democrat whose district includes San Quentin, called Brown’s decision “fantastic news.” He said the costs stemming from the new complex would have amounted to $1.6 billion over the next 20 years.

“”When you add it all up, I’d call this the $2 billion boondoggle,” he said in a phone interview.

KCBS and Chronicle Insider Phil Matier Comments:

Marin County filed a lawsuit in November to block the state from beginning construction on the facility.

The state already has spent $800,000 constructing a new death chamber at the nearly 160-year-old prison to comply with a federal judge’s 2006 order that California overhaul its lethal injection procedure.

Brown said the state will have to find an alternative way to address inmate housing needs.

He has proposed solving the state’s remaining $15.4 billion budget deficit through a mix of spending cuts and higher taxes.

(Copyright 2011 by CBSSan Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Wire services may have contributed to this report.)

More from Phil Matier
  • kc

    GOOD! Cram them all in, put those on death row with roommates, why should they get their own room when they have killed people, those on death row are the safest in prison; they don’t mix with other inmates, they get TV’s and such AND they will most likely die of natural causes before any death chamber gets them.

  • richard

    The pricks on death row deserve a new building?? What fruckkin moron ever approved this in the first place he should be shot.

  • Carl Christensen

    Brown always opposed the death penalty as does the new Atty General Harris. A phony reason to stop the construction despite the public’s well known feeling on this subject. Besides the lawyers can make millions on appeals that go on and on. Is this Justice?

  • Randy

    If they actually put to death, the people on death row, we wouldn’t need more spaces.

    • Jim

      and it would save millions of dollars not having to house and feed them, and pay for cable tv. Lets follow after Texas and get it done quickly and economically.

  • ‘Hanging Judge’ Challenges California’s Death Penalty « CBS San Francisco

    […] QUENTIN (CBS 5) — When Governor Jerry Brown canceled funding on Thursday for the proposed new death row facility at San Quentin, he said “we cannot justify a […]

  • ‘Hanging Judge’ Challenges California’s Death Penalty | All of California

    […] Penalty Posted on May 1, 2011 by admin SAN QUENTIN (CBS 5) — When Governor Jerry Brown canceled funding on Thursday for the proposed new death row facility at San Quentin, he said “we cannot justify a […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live