Yosemite Hikers Presumed Dead After Witnesses Confirm Waterfall Plunge

YOSEMITE NATIONAL PARK (CBS/AP) — Young tourists above one of Yosemite National Park’s beautiful and perilous waterfalls were trying to pose for a picture. Instead they burned a horrifying image into the memories of everyone who saw.

A man and a woman crossed a metal barricade above the 317-foot Vernal Fall on Tuesday, making their way over slick granite to a rock in the middle of the swift Merced River.

The woman slipped. The man reached for her and fell in. Another man in their group of about 10 tried to help but fell into the water as well. Other hikers, including several children in their group, could only watch as the rushing water swept all three students over the edge.

The couple who were on the rock hugged each other tightly as they disappeared.

“Everyone was screaming,” witness Jake Bibee said. “People were praying. What I will take away with me forever is the look on that grown man’s face as he was floating down that river knowing he was going to die and nobody could help them.”

A single sign in English warns visitors not to cross the barricade or swim in the waters above the falls. Bibee said other hikers had shouted that it wasn’t safe to go into the rushing river.

KCBS’ Holly Quan Reports:

The three students are presumed dead; rescuers continued searching for their bodies Wednesday. The Yosemite Search and Rescue unit identified them as Hormiz David, 22, of Modesto; Ninos Yacoub, 27, of Turlock; and Ramina Badal, 21, of Manteca.

The victims were part of a close-knit community of Christians from the Middle East who have been settling in California’s Central Valley during the past century.

They were members of the Mar Gewargis Parish in Ceres, where a prayer service was planned Wednesday evening. The church is part of the Assyrian Church of the East.

“It’s very shocking to our community,” said the Rev. Auchana Kanoun, who leads the parish.

Ninos Piro said outside the Mar Zaia Cathedral in Modesto that he was friends with all three victims, whom he knew from church.

David was studying music production at Modesto Junior College, Yacoub was studying chemistry at California State University, Stanislaus, and Badal attended the University of San Francisco and had hoped to become a doctor, Piro said.

“They were honest, righteous Christians trying to live their lives the right way,” said Piro, 36, of Turlock. “They were trying to be a good influence on everyone around them. That’s why you see everyone so torn up around here.”

The top of Vernal Fall is always treacherous, and is especially so this year because of the record snowmelt now under way. A metal barricade separates hikers from the river where it pools before crashing over the precipice.

On Wednesday afternoon, hundreds of tourists climbed the 1.5-mile Mist Trail to the top of Vernal Fall after the path was reopened.

Julie Ehrler of Modesto was on the trail with her mother-in-law but felt too uneasy to go all the way to the top of the falls. She called the loss of the three victims tragic.

“It makes you stop and think and not do silly things. I can understand they wanted to get close to it because it’s a beautiful site. But you have to be respectful toward nature.”

Bibee said other members of the victims’ group also had been on the wrong side of the barricade when he reached the top of the Mist Trail. One man, he said, was posing near the waterfall with a screaming young girl in his arms while a teenage girl snapped photographs.

“People became unglued on this guy,” Bibee said. “They said, ‘You know what man, get your ass back over here.”’

As that man walked back, Bibee said, the doomed couple made their way to the rock.

Bibee, a 28-year-old country western musician who has hiked the Mist Trail many times, said that before the victims were swept away he had spent a good part of his hike explaining to his companion how dangerous the wilderness can be.

“People come up here and they think it’s Disneyland,” he said.

Witnesses called 911 immediately after the accident. The search and rescue unit closed the Mist Trail on Tuesday afternoon while searching for the bodies. The trail, used by 1,500 people a day, was reopened Wednesday as rescuers searched the banks of the river.

The tragedy brings to six the number of people killed in water accidents in Yosemite this year. Two hikers drowned in the Hetch Hetchy Reservoir on June 29, and a hiker slipped and fell into the Merced River on the Mist Trail on May 13.

The deaths occurred in an especially dangerous year for visitors of mountainous areas in the West that experienced record winter snowfall. When temperatures heated up, it melted the snowpack and sent water cascading into rivers and streams.

Four family members died in Wyoming earlier in the week when a road collapsed and sent their car into a raging creek. Early assessments indicate the creek may have undermined the roadway. And in Utah, a 15-year-old girl died after heavy rains caused a huge sinkhole to open on a highway, swallowing a vehicle and causing her father’s SUV to careen off the road.

Charmain Morad-Daniel, a board member of the Assyrian National Council of Stanislaus, said she knew Badal well through the victim’s father and was acquainted with the men.

“I know three families that are really hurting,” she said. “It’s a tragedy for the Assyrian community because these are role models and they’re active in youth activities through the church.”

Badal and Yacoub were of Iraqi descent, she said.

Gewargis Narso, a deacon at the church the three victims attended, described Badal as respectful, nice and responsible.

“I wouldn’t have thought she would have taken a chance like that,” he said.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

  • http://blin90.wordpress.com/2011/07/20/plunge/ Plunge « Ben's Weblog

    […] here. Explore posts in the same categories: […]

  • Atrortfex

    Never mind, I figured out a way. Bring on the next pain in the ass DVD.

  • Alice

    Stupid is as stupid does. Don’t feel sorry for them at all, your in an area that clearly warns you of injury and/or death and you defy the signs and do what you want. I do feel sorry for those they leave behind.

    • Chris Pepper

      wow you don’t feel sorry at all? you sound heartless. I agree what they dd was stupid but I do feel sorry for them, it’s sad.

    • Donovan

      Alice, before calling anyone stupid, make sure you know the difference between “you’re” and “your.” Okay? Thanks.

      • kc

        I was thinking the same thing.

  • rs

    idiots. there are warning signs and a barricade for a reason.

  • christine

    as much of a tragedy as this is, it is also extremely frusterating. Having gone up there dozens of times, I’m sure others can also attest to seeing scores of people do the exact same thing these young adults did. it amazes me everytime that people can be so dumb! people do not take the warnings seriously because they think “that will never happen to me”. i cant tell you how many times i’ve seen familys WITH THEIR CHILDREN swimming in the waters just a few hundred feet from the falls. people need to understand that even in CALM waters, tragedies can still occur. one slip and you are a goner. prayers go out to the witnesses & family of those lost, as I’m sure those memories will haunt them for eternity.

  • Billy Floyd

    “Bibee said he was mortified when he reached the top of the Mist Trail and found members of the group on the river side of the barricade.”

    Why was he mortified? I can understand him being horrified, but since “mortified” means “extremely embarrassed,” this makes no sense.

    By the way: guard rails and warning signs are there for a reason. A good way not to be swept over a waterfall is to pay attention to them.

    • CommonSenseSays

      He probably MEANT ‘horrified’ but was too upset and mixed up the words. Quite understandably.

  • JaneQPublic

    Darwin strikes again. These people were idiots. One should NOT even need a posted warning sign in ‘several languages’ to see that this is dangerous. NATURE itself has posted the ‘warning’. My sympathy goes not to the morons who ignored the OBVIOUS DANGER, but to the people who were traumatized by watching the morons plunge.

  • HooDatIS?
  • kc

    We were in Yellowstone last month and it amazed me how many people ignore the signs around any geysers or pools… fragile ground, people have died and there are these idiots walking off the boardwalks to get closer. While we were there a woman fell in a “hole” having also crossed a barrier.
    I am sorry for the people they left behind. I feel much more sympathy for the witnesses, but people who ignore warning after warning eventually run into trouble.

  • http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2011/07/21/vigil-held-for-yosemite-hikers-swept-away-by-waterfall/ Vigil Held For Yosemite Hikers Swept Away By Waterfall « CBS San Francisco

    […] were on an all day church outing Tuesday when they climbed over the guard rail at the 317-foot Vernall Fall to pose for photographs, ignoring a warning sign that tells visitors on the Mist Trail not to cross the […]

  • smg

    unless it has changed, there is a giant *pictogram* on that sign of a body being flung over a waterfall. I wondered if this was a group indulging in alcoholic refreshment, until reading about the ‘respectful’ description– applies to their religious tradition, no doubt, but apparently not to natural law. one of those is essential for life on earth. very sorry for their community, and hope all who read the story apply it to their own blind spots.

  • http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2011/07/27/families-of-yosemite-falls-victims-continue-vigil-at-park/ Families Of Yosemite Falls Victims Continue Vigil At Park « CBS San Francisco

    […] {{url}}"}};}YOSEMITE NATIONAL PARK (CBS/AP) – Every day, relatives of the three young people swept over a Yosemite National Park waterfall travel to the park hoping to hear news about the whereabouts of the bodies. var videoCanvas = new […]

  • http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2011/08/01/san-ramon-woman-killed-in-fall-from-yosemite-half-dom/ San Ramon Woman Killed In Fall From Yosemite Half Dome « CBS San Francisco

    […] month, three people were swept to their deaths when they entered the Merced River above the 317-foot Vernal […]

  • http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2011/08/11/teen-dies-after-falling-on-yosemite-hiking-trail/ Teen Dies After Falling On Yosemite Hiking Trail « CBS San Francisco

    […] Fall, and signs warn hikers that mist from the fall can make the trail slippery. Three hikers were swept over the falls last month after ignoring barriers to the Merced reiver, witnesses […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live