kpix-masthead kcbs-black-masthead

Latest News

Man Shot While Feeding Oakland Homeless Dies

View Comments
The East Oakland scene where a man was shot while feeding the homeless on 47th Avenue.

The East Oakland scene where a man was shot while feeding the homeless on 47th Avenue.

OAKLAND (CBS SF) — The murder of a man who was helping feed homeless people in East Oakland “is an outrage,” Oakland Police Chief Anthony Batts said Thursday.

Batts said 29-year-old Paris Powell, who was known on the streets as “Brother John,” was “trying to make a difference in the lives of homeless people.”

Oakland Mayor Jean Quan said, “This one is not explainable at all. I hope it was a case of mistaken identity.”

Quan said she plans to meet with Powell’s family to express her condolences.

Powell was pronounced dead at 10:25 p.m. Wednesday.

Oakland police said he was shot in an industrial area in the 1000 block of 47th Avenue at about 12:30 a.m. Wednesday while he, his wife and two step-children, ages 3 and 7, were handing out food to homeless people.

KCBS’ Anna Duckworth Reports:

At noon on Thursday, there was a small vase with red and orange flowers near the site where Powell was shot.

Powell’s death was mourned by 61-year-old formerly homeless man William Holloway, who witnessed the shooting incident and said Powell regularly gave him food and checked up on him.

Holloway now works as a security guard at a pallet company in the block where the shooting occurred. He also lives in a tiny two-room house on the pallet company’s property.

Holloway said Powell, his wife and step-children were in the midst of giving him food when Powell was shot.

He said Powell and his family were in a Ford Aerostar van when a young, light-skinned black man who was in a late model turquoise Ford Aerostar van came around the corner and opened fire.

Oakland police have not provided a description of the suspect or his van.

The suspect, who was alone, “fired three shots right away and then fired two more after that,” Holloway said.

Powell was shot in the face and “caught most of the bullets,” Holloway said.

Holloway said he ducked down to avoid getting hit and Powell’s wife and stepchildren started screaming after Powell was hit.

He said Powell’s wife, who is pregnant, was grazed by a bullet but she did not notice until about 30 minutes later because she was in shock from the shooting.

The 3-year-old girl also suffered a minor flesh wound, Holloway said.

He said he and Powell’s family did not have a cell phone, so he rushed over to a nearby callbox to summon help from police.

“I hope they catch the suspect but I think it’s going to be very difficult,” Holloway said.

He said he was too busy dodging bullets to get a good look at the suspect or get the license plate number of the suspect’s van.

Batts said he thinks there is a good chance the suspect will be caught, saying, “The Oakland Police Department is good at tracking down bad guys.”

But he did not provide any specific information about why the suspect might be caught.

Batts said there is a $25,000 reward for information leading to the arrest of the suspect.

Holloway said Powell, whom he only knew as Brother John, has provided food to homeless people in a wide swath of East Oakland for the past year.

He said about three months ago Powell told him that he was frustrated because the homeless people he was trying to help did not appreciate his efforts.

Holloway said he told Powell that he appreciated his work and “as long as one person appreciates you, that’s good.”

He said Powell “smiled at me and said, ‘Thank you, Bill.’”

Holloway said he’s not afraid to give his name to reporters or have his face shown on television even though he could be a target because he’s a witness to the shooting.

“I’m not worried about it,” he said. “When it’s my time to go, it’s my time to go.”

However, Holloway said the pallet company’s owner wants him to leave because he thinks the suspect might retaliate against Holloway.

“I’m a liability now,” he said.

Holloway said he might become homeless again and sleep underneath the BART tracks that are near the pallet company.

“If I have to go, I have to go,” Holloway said.

Told that Holloway might become homeless again, Oakland police Lt. Ersie Joyner said city officials would try to provide help for him.

“We’ll do what we can for him,” Joyner said.

Anyone with information about the shooting is encouraged to call the Police Department’s homicide section at (510) 238-3821 or email oaklandhomicide@oaklandnet.com.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

View Comments
  • Miss Dee

    How sad! While I don’t agree with having your young children out at midnight any Bay Area neighborhood especially a crime ridden area, this is such senseless violence! There was just no point or reason behind this man’s death. My heart goes out to his wife & children. This has got to stop.

    • Steven

      Oakland is a predominantly Black area, especially that section. A White do-gooder gets shot. You do the math.

      Let them starve.

      • changomango

        Well said! These savages don’t give a damn about anybody, even those they try to help them, they’re savages who belong in a zoo or six feet under.

      • john

        His own ignorance killed him.

      • Coleman Kyles

        The real racism comes from those who assume that because this man was doing something good, he was White. Paris Powell was one of the numerous Black men that exist everyday in America. Despite what the media chooses to show us.

      • rmh

        he was a black man

      • Wang Chung

        Yeah, Baby – preach it, preach it !!! You nailed it

      • rmh

        and a better man than me

      • Roni

        Why do you assume the victim is white? There was no information on his race in the article and I don’t think race had anything to do with this crime. It could be something as simple as a gang initiation. This is a sad tragedy caused by one stupid individual; not some kind of race war.

      • TT

        The do-gooder was black.

      • Ernaldo T

        I wonder what color the shooter is? Am I being racist? Hahahahaha

      • jesus22

        IT’S SAD, YOU CAN’T EVEN HELP PEOPLE ANYMORE.THEY SHOULD HANG THAT GUY.ILL SEND HIM STRAIGHT TO HELL.

    • Jimbo Klokenstien

      Dont argue about what happened and what race anyone was…. Someone was shot for doing something very nice and making someones day. Like miss dee said it, my heart goes out to his wife and children.

      • urdrwho10

        Goodness no, we would never want to actually talk about the heart of the problem would we. Oh no no, that just wouldn’t be correct.

        There is nothing to discuss about the violence in particular societies and group dynamics. Why….good people just don’t talk about such things.

  • Jason

    Batman has been born

    • Massimo Deportado

      Sad but you’re probably right.

  • Young Buck

    Get a rope.

  • Mark Matis

    You nailed it. Typical Obama Behavior.

  • Massimo Deportado

    $1000 says Morgana99 is the NUMBER ONE suspect in this shooting!

    See how easy it is to be a feckless, mindless lib?

  • Booga

    I bet you 3 Trillion I(don’t)OU Bucks from the Private owned Federally Reserve Bank hat those reporters making money off of this story didn’t feed any of the homeless or do anything at all for them.

    • Massimo Deportado

      Ooga to that!

  • Greycoat

    “… IF he didn’t come over from a link on the Drudge Report.” You obviously know of the link and therefore visited Drudge yourself which is proof any idiot can visit Drudge for it is open to everyone.

  • larry

    The authorities have been trying to stop people from feeding the homeless by issuing tickets and there was citizen outrage everywhere. I hope this drives home the point. There are homeless shelter that dishes out food let them go there for a free meal.

    • Lady V

      … and if they’d rather die than they’d better do it, and decrease the surplus population!

  • Joseph Merican

    Sounds like a gang initiation to me…

  • Chad

    I honestly cannot believe that there are people in this country so full of hatred in their hearts that they think this man was doing something ‘wrong’ by feeding homeless people. I bet you call yourselves “Christians’, as well, right ? If Jesus was killed while handing out fish and bread to the poor in his day, would you say that he got what he deserved ?

    You people are truly despicable, and should be ashamed of your lack of empathy for your fellow man.

    • Daniel Cline

      here here, my we all rest a little better knowing these racists probably lose a little sleep every night rotting in there own beliefs. come to the other side racists,..you’ll live better.

      • Anthony

        You must be one of these “hug a terrorist, we love you” idiots. I wish you would try your method, I would love to see the latest video from the jihad. “american idiot gets his head cut off, with a dirty rusty spoon, while offering hugs to islam”

        Please, make my day.

    • Ernaldo T

      So, tell me again why Jesus was killed.

    • jesus22

      THANK YOU CHAD.THEY WOULD SAY I DESERVED IT.HEY THEY CRUCIFIED ME,CAN’T GET ANY WORST THAN THAT, YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN..

  • Real Ed

    “Sean Patriot” & “Young Buck” – you are not a patriots, you are a pathetic racists. Morganna99 – I have seen more opression and racism out of the left than I have from people who follow the Drudge Report.

    • Daniel Cline

      sean is a pround racist too. they’re the scariest type.

    • BigGirl

      And an Amish man killed the white man? Hardly.

  • Real Ed

    Whoa! Someone buy this guy a thesaurus.

    • Daniel Cline

      I’d rather buy him a plane ticket out of the USA.

    • Go live with the blacks Ed

      Real Ed was Jangle Leg’s woman in Alameda prison.

  • Real Ed

    I am sure when you wrote “YOUR” you intended to use the contraction of “YOU ARE” commonly spelled “YOU’RE”. You may want to polish up your education before you bring it out in the light.

    • John McCombs

      LOL. Why can’t people get it right? Is it really that difficult? My personal favorite is “loosers” instead of “losers”.

    • jumpjump

      To Real Ed the genius.The period after You’re in your reply should be inside the quotes, not outside. To use your own words “You may want to polish up your education before you bring it out in the light.” See how easy that was? He’s an idiot, you’re an arrogant fool.

  • gerald

    This guy and his family were in about 99.9% certainty targeted for attack for being WHITE in a area that is primarily black.

    real story.

    while he may have been feeding homeless blacks at the time, the story tagline implies that he was attacked for his actions, when in fact almost any WHITE person in that area would have faced a risk or robbery, attack, rape or violence of some kind.

  • Terry L. Walker

    No good deed goes unpunished.

  • Moody

    There is a reason why people refer to Oakland as a toilet. A good man just got gunned down for no reason. Welcome to inner city trash.

    • Daniel Cline

      he wasn’t guned down for no reason he was shot because he was in the wrong hood with the the wrong colors. he didn’t follow the rules of the streets. I lived in Oakland for 6 years and I know not to go there at night. (yes I’m white) the streets have rules. you need to respect the rules.

      • Amerigo VesPUCHI

        Cline, you’re not white, you’re a jew and know the difference.

        Jews love all racial tension, and defend this “senseless action” by calling anybody rightfully cautious as “racist”.

        Let them go feed the zoo, but teach your friends and neighbors the truth. Better this braindead pacifist gets popped than an awakened White man.

        Incogman.net before they shut it down again.

      • Observer

        “The streets have rules”…really, really! NO, it’s the lazy, living on the public dole, drug infested trash who prowl the streets at night that have the rules. For some who have to live in this self created war zone, the news is good, it will be over soon. For others, not so good – The night crawlers will spend the next seven years destroying the cities, the world and everything around them. Then, it too shall end.

  • Chippy55

    I thought Clinton got rid of all the hungry and homeless? And why doesn’t Pelosi use some of her millions to simply feed a few people. Oh that’s right, she’d have to create ANOTHER Gov’t agency to give away Federal Tax dollars, because Libs never help anyone, unless it’s with tax dollars. And we know that people like Gore and Biden don’t give to charity because of their 1040s.

    • Daniel Cline

      chippy you never help anyone. you box of crayons only has black and white in it.

  • Toady

    It’s better not to feed the homeless and enable the lifestyle. It might encourage them to go to a shelter or charity and get the permanent help they need.

    • Daniel Cline

      Toady do you really believe in permanent help for the homeless. have you ever had a hard drug problem or a mentel illness?

      • Voice of Reason

        I have. I not only had a serious problem with drugs it lead to me being first homeless, then to prison.

        When I got out of prison I was determined to change my life and I did. I didn’t suck off the system either.

        I put my nose to the grindstone, did menial jobs and went to college. JuCo to start then beased on my grades was offered a scholarship to Cal Poly.

        It is doable chief. You have to want “it” more than you want what you have or had.

        I don’t know if this man was enabling these folks……but many do and it sounds like he was no different.

        I applaud his altruism, but as toady stated, he actually may have been doing more harm than good.

        No arguing that his actions got him killed and darn near the rest of his family. His children are likely traumatized for life.

        Go work at a shelter. Give of your money and time to missions you know and trust.

        Hanging out ANYWHERE in OakTown after dark is a recipe for disaster.

    • Ernaldo T

      Or maybe even a job? hahahahha

  • Slappy

    Hey, you guys gotta give the violent hood rats some benefit of the doubt, they probably didn’t see that those whites were feeding the homeless. I mean, how dark was it outside?

    Seriously, $10 says the perps are black. Aside from the Latinos, who the hell else would shoot at kids?

    • Daniel Cline

      if you want to hand out food you have to ask for the gangs permission first. they run the streets.

      • James Crow

        The only thing keeping the men of America from fixing this problem is the govt. Blacks are a protected species.

      • JaneQPublic

        @ Daniel (and all the other cowards) BS – so long as you behave like a gutless worm and cowtow to tyranny – including gangs – YOU will never be a real man.

        My sincere condolences to the Good Samaitan’s family. At least he died as a real man doing what he could to help others. THAT is a worthwhile legacy which can be passed on to his children.

  • Daniel Cline

    no sean as a bigot you might have trouble understanding this. you can’t ignor the rules of the streets. period.

    • dtech

      I’d rather the streets have the laws of our society enforced, rather than the rule of thugs. Your response epitomizes the problem with our inner cities. And before you say it, I’m no more a bigot than you are. This has nothing to do with skin color – or at least, it shouldn’t.

      • Janet Napolitano

        I agree, Daniel Cline is an idiot with too much time on his hands!

    • Ed

      Sure. Now name one predominantly white “street” where this would happen. Face it, that area is just a great big zoo with not a keeper in sight.

  • Daniel Cline

    I love drudge it helps me frame the conservative view better. which basically is something like, ” we fear anything not like ourselves.”

    • Janet Napolitano

      Newsflash: Yes, we fear murderous ghetto thugs with guns!

    • spike

      You obviously dont actually READ drudge. He has links to darn near EVERYBODY on both the left and right. If you actually looked you’d know that.

  • JMWinPR

    How very sad. Prayers go to the family.
    It was LBJ not WJC who solved homelessness and hunger,
    This story does remind me of a WJC moment……..feeding the warlords in Somalia

    • Voice of Reason

      LBJ sure did a bang up job huh?

  • MEC

    The bleeding hearts live in an Ivory Tower. Hardly any of their heartfelt actions change anything but for a few for a very brief time.

    Get real!! Society is predatory. Forget the sandwiches and a warm coat; buy a gun.

    • Ernaldo T

      Coming soon, guaranteed……

    • Tyrell McPimpscoon

      AMEN, Mec…couldn’t have said it any better

  • Bedford Forrest

    We have people in urban areas who are more dangerous than Pit Bulls, wolves or bears. At least the aforementioned animals won’t rape you and kill you. Our
    urban minorities are maybe the most wild dangerous animals since the Russian army entered Berlin.I personally don’t like being PC, I call it the way I see it.We outnumber the bad guys so much that they should fear us, and I hope to see the day, we settle this account.

    • Amerigo VesPUCHEE

      You got that right!

      Check out Incogman.net before they shut it down again, and if you agree, spread the word.

  • http://lonelyconservative.com/2011/07/man-gunned-down-while-feeding-the-homeless/ Man Gunned Down While Feeding the Homeless | The Lonely Conservative

    [...] John” was feeding the homeless in Oakland when he was gunned down and killed in the street. CBS San Francisco has the sad news:Police have not released his name, but a witness told CBS 5 Wednesday that he was [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!