UC Berkeley Grads Sentenced To Eight Years In Iranian Prison

TEHRAN (CBS SF) — Two University of California at Berkeley graduates arrested more than two years ago while hiking along the Iraq-Iran border have been sentenced to eight years in prison on charges that include espionage, state TV reported Saturday, a sharp blow to hopes their release was imminent.

The announcement seemed to send a hard-line message from Iran’s judiciary – which answers directly to the ruling clerics – weeks after the country’s foreign minister suggested that the trial of Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal could clear the way for their freedom.

KCBS’ Anna Duckworth Reports:

It also was likely to raise speculation about Iran using the Americans as political bargaining chips and could bring added tensions to Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s expected visit to New York next month for the annual General Assembly at the United Nations.

Authorities did not immediately confirm the report and made no further comment – although it was carried on Iran’s highly controlled state media, which is frequently used to make high-profile announcements.

In Washington, State Department Spokeswoman Victoria Nuland restated U.S. appeals for their release. “It is time to reunite them with their families,” she said.

A spokeswoman for the men’s relatives said only that the families were aware of the report and awaiting confirmation.

“They are asking for privacy during this difficult time,” Samantha Topping said.

The Americans, whose final court hearing was three weeks ago, deny the charges and say they were only hiking in a scenic and largely peaceful area of northern Iraq near the porous border.

They were detained in July 2009 along with a third American, Sarah Shourd, who was released in September 2010 on $500,000 bail and returned to the United States. Shourd’s case “is still open,” the state-run TV website irinn.ir reported.

Bauer and Fattal, both 29, have been sentenced to three years each for illegal entry into Iran and five years each for spying for the United States, the website quoted “informed sources” at Iran’s judiciary as saying. It was not immediately clear if that includes time served. They have 20 days to appeal the sentence.

Their Iranian attorney, Masoud Shafiei, said he has not been notified of the verdict but he will definitely appeal the sentence if true.

“I’ve not been notified of any verdict in the case of my clients,” Shafiei told The Associated Press. “This is a strong verdict inconsistent with the charges.”

It’s unclear what maximum sentence was possible by the Revolutionary Court, which handles state security issues. Espionage can bring the death penalty, but handing the sentence to a foreigner is unknown legal territory in Iran.

Iran insists that its judiciary is independent from political currents, but Iranian officials have used the detained Americans to draw attention to alleged mistreatment of Iranians in U.S. prisons and others who were held by U.S. forces in Iraq. The report on the sentences came just two days after President Barack Obama made his most direct call for the resignation of Syrian President Bashar Assad, who remains among Iran’s closest Mideast allies.

The case, meanwhile, has added to tensions between the United States and Iran that were already high over other issues, including Tehran’s disputed nuclear program.

But Iran also recognizes the potential for goodwill gestures. Shourd’s release – assisting with talks by Oman – came last year as Ahmadinejad was preparing for the annual U.N. gathering of world leaders.

The Americans say they mistakenly crossed into Iran when they stepped off a dirt road while hiking near a waterfall in the Kurdish region of Iraq. While other parts of Iraq remain troubled by violence, the semiautonomous Kurdish north has drawn tourists in recent years, including foreigners.

The U.S. government has appealed for the two men to be released, insisting that they have done nothing wrong. The two countries have no direct diplomatic relations, so Washington has been relying on an interests section at the Swiss Embassy in Tehran to follow the case.

Earlier this month, Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Salehi said he hoped “the trial of the two American defendants who were detained for the crime of illegally entering Iran will finally lead to their freedom.” Their lawyer also had expressed hope they might receive a pardon for the Islamic holy month of Ramadan.

Shourd is back living in Oakland, California; Bauer grew up in Onamia, Minnesota; and Fattal is from suburban Philadelphia. The last direct contact family members had with Bauer and Fattal was in May 2010 when their mothers were permitted a short visit in Tehran.

Their case most closely parallels that of freelance journalist Roxana Saberi, an Iranian-American who convicted of spying before being released in May 2009. Saberi was sentenced to eight years in prison, but an appeals court reduced that to a two-year suspended sentence and let her return to the U.S.

At the time, a spokesman for the Iranian judiciary said the court ordered the reduction as a gesture of “Islamic mercy” because Saberi had cooperated with authorities and expressed regret.

In May 2009, a French academic, Clotilde Reiss, also was freed after her 10-year sentence on espionage-related charges was commuted.

Last year, Iran freed an Iranian-American businessman, Reza Taghavi, was held for 29 months for alleged links to a bombing in the southern city of Shiraz, which killed 14 people. Taghavi denied any role in the attack.

Supporters of the detained hikers have expressed their disappointment and anger over the decision on Facebook and Twitter Saturday morning.

Many of the responders said that they had not given up hope that the two men will be released despite the sentence.

“Never give up hope,” one supporter posted on the Free the Hikers Facebook page. “Working together we will get Shane & Josh home and it’s not going to be in 8 years. Lace up the boots and let’s get back to work.”

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

More from Anna Duckworth
  • todd1952

    I think it’s time to round up every Iranian in this country on a visa and expel them. Also time to keep everyone inside the Iranian embassy in Washington, D.C. and not let them exit, the way Iranians did with the American embassy during the Carter administration after the Ayatollah Khomeini became religious dictator when the former Shah was exiled.

    • Chris Wingbert

      i think we shouldnt do any of the things you just said. Instead we should send that bail jumper Sarah shourd back to Iran so she can serve the eight years with these two idiots.

      • c

        Exactly right. The bail jumper is probably why the other two got hammered.

  • Philip Scharfy

    I don’t understand why our illustrious, ever successful, Sec of Staye,cHillary Klinton didn’t fly over there on her broom to doa deal to get these knumskulls (I mean how dumb can you be to go “hiking” on the Iraniasn border) out of jail.

    For someone with pretensions to the Presidency one would ave thought we’d see a little more effort on her part. Couldn’t she have issued her standaRD “DIRE CONSEQUENCES” THREAT WHICH TURNED THE cHINESE AND nORTH kOREANS INTO QUIVERING BOWLS OF JELLY?

  • Cobrawing

    As someone just said, how dumb to go hiking on the Iranian border. If the Devil showed up down on the corner looking to take souls people would line up to get his autograph! Unreal how stupid people can be.

  • Tom

    I guess I don’t understand why these young people just had to ‘hike’ along the Iran/Iraq border. With all the turmoil that region has gone through for years I would think that they could find somewhere else to go. They should have realized that the US has no friends in the Middle East and that their presence would be construed, correctly or incorrectly, as espionage. I guess that their error will now cost them eight years of their young lives and that is a damn shame.

  • Vincent Chew

    First let me say that these people are spies and were caught. They will be traded for Talaban terrorist in cuba. If they are not spies than they are the dumbest people in the world. Liberalism at Berkely has damaged their brain. Liberalism is a disease. If they are spies than they are true Americans fighting for freedom.

    • rodge stone

      there is no such thing as conservatives, they often got caught in the strip club…ask Micheal Steel !!!

      • Titainiumman

        What about flatulant Bawny Frank having a gay brothel in his basement?

    • Dirka Dirka

      Liberals do not believe in spying homie. Put your crack pipe away. Fuk these fools. You go to another county, guess what you play by their rules.

    • Titainiumman

      C’mon,With the intelligence level of Berkeley grads,the government could easily find smarter persons to spy for them.If that’s what they were doing.I believe that are just two stupid idealist numbskulls that saw no problem crossing a border to a country that loathes america something they probably share with the Irainians.

  • erikmoon

    They should never have gone there. Two countries in the middle of turmoil, you deserve it. Morons

  • james

    Stupid, middle class,liberal berkley fools.Who the hell goes hiking along the Iraq – Iran border? They deserve jailing for their sheer arrogance and stupidity!

  • Big Red

    If you travel to a foreign country, you must learn to respect their customs and laws. In this case, this means not crossing over their border.

    While I wish no ill will on the two travelers, I do not want to see this situation being used as leverage against the U.S.

    Stop running stories on this and stirring up public opinion for their release. We already did it once for those idiot journalists in North Korea a few years back, let’s not do it again.

  • Yoda99

    First we had those two ding-a-lings hiking on the N. Korean border. Now we got these dumbbells on the Iranian border. It wouldn’t shock me one bit to hear we’ve got some more idiots hiking right now on the Libyan border If there are and they get caught, my reaction is as follows . . . YAWN.

  • Movie Mike

    Must be more to this story than is being reported. What were they really doing hiking on the border. It’s not logical, even for Berkeley Grads.

    • Titainiumman

      How right you are,This just shows you how stupid berkeley grads are.

  • Ben

    Nobody is this stupid. They must have been spying, just like that guy arrested in Egypt a couple of months ago. There must be some kind of cowardly program to use unlikely civilians to spy.

  • Titainiumman

    Being Berkeley students say quite alot about these two stupid losers,Who in their right mind would get anywhere near a border of a country that despises america?Maybe they assumed that because they are liberals that the Irainian government was going to welcome them with open arms as comrads

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live