Civic Center, Powell Stations Closed In BART Protest, Dozens Arrested

SAN FRANCISCO (CBS / AP) — Police have arrested roughly three dozen protesters and have reopened two downtown San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit stations that were closed during Monday evening’s commute.

About 100 demonstrators on Monday were protesting the transit agency’s decision to cut wireless service in its San Francisco stations earlier this month to quell another demonstration. BART’s action touched off a worldwide debate over free speech and prompted retaliation by hackers.

The Civic Center station was closed around 5:30 p.m. and the Powell Street station closed around 5:45 p.m. After a series of closures, BART announced both stations were once again open as of 8:30 p.m.

A few dozen protesters gathered on the Civic Center BART platform at 5 p.m. BART quickly closed the station when protests began; arresting several protesters that raised their voices, declaring it was illegal to protest on the BART platform.

The protesters chose the platform to gather because Charles Hill was killed there by a BART police officer on July 3, after Hill allegedly attacked the officer with a knife. The shooting set off a string of protests that have shut down San Francisco BART stations three times since then.

After being ordered to leave the station, demonstrators moved to the street, joining with other protesters already there, and 50-60 started marching east on Market Street. They blocked traffic, yelling “No justice, no peace!” and “Hey BART, what do you say, how many kids did you kill today?”

Police on foot escorted the protesters on either side, directing traffic with motorcycles in front of the march, and police cars in the rear.

When protesters arrived at the Ferry Building at Embarcadero Plaza, they demanded to be let into the building. Police blocked protesters from entering, while employees peered out at the unruly mob. Some demonstrators wore masks, others carried signs against censorship and police brutality, and two even protested naked.

Shortly after, protesters turned around to march back west on Market Street. The protest grew as they marched, and at certain points there were more than 100 demonstrators.

They marched to United Nations Plaza, outside the Civic Center BART station, where they briefly gathered in the plaza around a portable radio playing dance music. A handful of protesters then blocked Market Street outside the plaza, between Seventh and Eighth streets.

Police then announced the demonstration on Market Street was illegal, as it blocked traffic in both directions, even holding up a San Francisco Municipal Railway train proceeding west on Market Street.

Police made several arrests as they tried to push the crowd back onto the sidewalk. Protesters set off firecrackers and pushed police lines, but were eventually corralled back onto the sidewalk.

Protesters then took off east again, this time running at times to stay ahead of police, lighting smoke bombs and throwing them into the street, and overturning garbage cans.

Protesters darted in and out of the streets, running to avoid police, before reconvening and marching nearly to Montgomery Street. They turned around before reaching Montgomery Street, heading back west.

At the corner of Market and Fourth streets, police attempted to disrupt protesters by forming a line and demanding protesters return to the sidewalk. At least one protester was arrested, held down by several police as he lay on his stomach in the middle of the busy intersection. Protesters were scattered between the corners, yelling at police that held them on the sidewalk.

A group of about 40 protesters reconvened west of the police lines and started marching west on Market Street again, blocking traffic without a police escort. More demonstrators used garbage cans to block traffic and threw firecrackers into the street.

At Grove Street the demonstrators turned right, and some shouted that they were marching to City Hall. But police formed a line at Larkin Street, and used batons to force protesters onto the sidewalk, knocking several to the pavement.

About 40 protesters and some members of the media were detained in an encirclement of police on Grove Street between Market Street and Larkin Street. As of 9 p.m., police were still in the process of making arrests.

The protests forced the closure of the Civic Center and Powell Street stations at several points throughout the evening. Civic Center was closed for a total of two hours and 36 minutes and Powell Street for a total of one hour and 38 minutes, according to BART.

Monday night marks the third time since July 11 that protests caused station closures during rush hour in San Francisco.

On July 11, the group No Justice, No BART organized a protest in response to the BART police shooting of Hill. During that demonstration, protesters blocked train doors to prevent them from leaving the station, resulting in the closure of three San Francisco BART stations.

On Aug. 11, BART said it had intelligence that another more disruptive protest was being planned and shut down cellphone service in several stations to prevent protesters from communicating in stations and tunnels.

That protest failed to materialize, leading BART spokesman Linton Johnson to declare the precaution was successful in disrupting the protest.

But blocking cellphone service has drawn more attention to BART. Civil rights groups have blasted BART for the unusual tactic, calling it illegal and unconstitutional.

The hacker protest group “Anonymous” reacted angrily, and called on their loose collective of members to hack BART websites, flood BART offices with emails, faxes and phone calls, and called for another protest on Aug. 15.

That protest shut down all four downtown San Francisco BART stations, leaving commuters trapped outside of locked gates.

BART has continued to defend the decision to block cellphone service, most recently in a letter to BART customers Saturday explaining the service disruptions and stressing that stopping cellphone service was necessary to ensure safety on the platform.

BART’s defense has not stopped criticism of the agency, however. On Monday, the National Lawyers Guild released its own statement condemning BART’s actions as unconstitutional.

“The BART decision to terminate cellphone service during public protests is an unconstitutional prior restraint on free speech precisely designed to censor criticism of the deadly use of force by BART police,” the statement said.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)


    why weren’t more protestors on the platform arrested? THe platform is private property and protestors are disrupting the peace and impacting commuters, they can assemble outside but when they close stations they should be sent to jail!

    • GO Bart! all you hipster die

      This country has become too lenient on protesters who disturb the peace, INCREASE THE FINES SO THEY’LL THINK TWICE BEFORE RUINING PEOPLE’S LIVES.

      • james

        wake up you zombie

  • RCL

    these people need to get a life… people have jobs/families to get to.

    • lil old lady

      These people don’t care. They’re too selfish to think beyond the end of their noses.

  • Ricardo Hartley

    Animals. What are they protesting again? Oh yeah, another LAWFUL and APPROPRIATE use of force by police against an armed criminal.

    Doesn’t matter what culture you are from, what language you speak, or what race you are. Shoot at police, police will shoot back. Point a knife or other weapon at Police and/or try to stab them police will shoot you. Fight with cops and/or try to flee? Police will use force, duh.

    When will these ignorant protesting morons figure that out? Probably never, because they’re too dumb.

    • lil old lady

      These protesters seem to feel that it’s ok to shoot at, pull a gun or knife on and threaten the police and not face the consequences of their actions. When an idiot tries to fight the police or run and is stopped, they scream “Police brutality” because forcde has to be used to bring them down.

      Please, don’t call them animals. That’s too good for them and an insult to animals.

  • luckypaul

    … and BART kept Civic Center closed long after KCBS announced it was open! Why was Civic Center closed–and more press milling around than BART employees? Why was there no information available? Why is BART’s web page not filled with up to the minute information about the status of their stations? The only answer is that the BART administration and employees are clueless? Were the Civic Center Monday night staff still on duty? Did they close and go home?

  • John F

    Mayor, please stop these lunatic protestors and nip it in the bud before it spreads further and really gets out of control. Lock them all up and fine them heavily to discourage further behavior of this sort. I’d hate for these riot inciters to keep fanning the flames for it to grow into another London type riot…..

    • SOMAtwocents

      I agree. Let’s declare open season on anyone who interferes with the normal working of the commute. There should be a zero tolerance policy and maximum force should be used the instant anyone tries to interfere with normal operations. All commuters should be ready to defend their commute even if it means escalating to deadly force!

    • Get yo Hands Off My Bag freak

      these freaking losers should be ashamed of themselves
      they need a hobby or a darn job
      it aint BART they made at, their made at themselves for being failures
      BART should not have cutt phone service and they are lucky nothing bad freaking happened

  • connie

    We the people need to take back our lives from these sleazy protestors..
    We need to kick and push these trouble makers onto the 3rd rail !
    bring base ball bats with you..and learn to defend your selves from these wanabe terrorists!

  • duncan

    If you’re not a liberal at 20 you have no heart, if not a conservative at 30 you have no brain

  • Ralph

    So how are knocking over trashcans, throwing fireworks and smokebombs and trying to invade the Ferry Building part of a protest over a man’s shooting and BART’s (wise) decision to shut off cell service?

  • Tours Martel

    The Oakland police demonstrated the correct way to deal with anarchist protestors at the beginning of the Iraq war. They whacked the heck out of the protestors’ shins with batons and rubber bullets. Bruised the poor babies no end. The anarchists whined to the media and sued for payment, but never came back. All talk and no trousers!

  • Mark

    I agree with other commenters. The authorities, police, and BART are being far too lenient with these latter day anarchists and nihilists. They WANT to cause as much trouble as they can to advance their agenda, and they’ll push it as far as can until they are stopped. How bad does it have to get? They LIVE for disruption and destruction. First Amendment? Please! The wireless service in the stations is BART’s infrastructure; they can turn it off if they want. It’s not as if cell phone service was cut in all of SF. What spoiled, whining brats. Grow up!

  • Mark

    Has anyone else noticed how the media coverage–including the story above–barely mentions all the decent, ordinary people who are inconvenienced and disrupted by these sanctimonious losers? Do they really think we are all going to rise up and attack BART, or burn down City Hall? What a joke. Once more, with feeling: GROW UP!

  • David Maxwell

    Spray them with synthetic mountain lion urine, they’ll disperse.

  • PLW

    Good job! Arrest those Dirt Bags and hold them accountable for their illegal actions. About time!

  • reggie

    anarchy is not the answer

  • Group Organizing BART Protests In SF Vows To Continue Fight « CBS San Francisco

    […] Related tags Anonymous, Arrests, BART, BART Protests, Civic Center, Commuters, Police, Powell, Protests, Service Disruptions, Tim Ryan var addthis_product = 'wpp-261'; var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};if (typeof(addthis_share) == "undefined"){ addthis_share = {"templates":{"twitter":"{{title}} {{url}}"}};}SAN FRANCISCO (CBS SF) – Members of the loosely organized hacking group “Anonymous” said they would continue protests at Bay Area Rapid Transit stations in San Francisco, after disrupting the evening commute for the second straight week on Monday. […]

  • Bob

    Time for BART commuters to open a can of kick ass on those wannabe protesters.

  • jamie

    wow, what country do you disgusting losers want to live in? I mean you to the above commentators not the heroic actions of these protestors who are fighting for all of us whether you like it or not. Once your children become a target of the police you’ll change your tune. I take bart everyday multiple times. I see more disruption from sporting events than these protests and at least the protestors aren’t wasted and trying to get in my pants.

  • BART To Hear Public Comments On Cellphone Service Shutdown « CBS San Francisco

    […] The latest protest on Monday night temporarily shut down two San Francisco stations and resulted in about 40 people being arrested. […]

  • BART Police Chief Vows Vigilance Regarding Passenger Safety « CBS San Francisco

    […] “Anonymous.” That group has been the lead organizers of protests the last two Mondays that disrupted service for hours in downtown San […]

  • Familiar Names Appear On SF BART Protest Arrest List « CBS San Francisco

    […] {{url}}"}};}SAN FRANCISCO (CBS 5) – We are learning more about the 35 people who were arrested during Monday evening’s BART protest, which shut down two downtown San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit stations at several points […]

  • Protesters Target BART For 3rd Straight Monday « CBS San Francisco

    […] Last Monday’s protest resulted in the closure of the Civic Center and Powell Street stations and the arrest of about 40 people by San Francisco police. […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live