Central Valley Serial Killer’s Tip Leads To Remains Of 2nd Body

SAN ANDREAS, Calaveras County (CBS / AP) — Information provided by a California death row inmate who was one of the two notorious “Speed Freak Killers” led to the discovery Friday of a second set of human remains, this time believed to belong to a 16-year-old girl who went missing nearly three decades ago.

Specially trained dogs led authorities to a partial human skull and bones buried on a remote Calaveras County property, said Deputy Les Garcia, spokesman for the San Joaquin County Sheriff’s Department, which is leading the search.

Garcia said it would take some time for the Department of Justice to make a positive identification.

KCBS’ Melissa Culross Reports:

However, the parents of Chevelle “Chevy” Wheeler said authorities notified them that the remains were discovered where death row inmate Wesley Shermantine said they would find their daughter, who disappeared while skipping school in 1985. Shermantine was convicted of her murder, which authorities say was part of a methamphetamine-fueled killing spree committed by him and his childhood friend, Loren Herzog, from the 1980s until their arrests in 1999.

“They said they found her wrapped in a blanket,” Paula Wheeler, the girl’s mother, told The Associated Press in a phone interview from the family’s home in Crossville, Tenn. “This is a happy day. We can finally have some closure.”

The Wheelers say they plan to cremate their daughter and bring her home with them to Tennessee, where they moved after her disappearance.

On Thursday, the same dogs led the same searchers to a site containing another skull and bones thought to belong to Cyndi Vanderheiden, a 25-year-old last seen in front of her Linden home in 1998.

The searchers found all the remains in an area near property once owned by the family of Shermantine.

Prompted by a Sacramento bounty hunter’s promise to pay him money, Shermantine has been hand-drawing maps from his Death Row cell that authorities are using to search three sites.

Along with the two nearby sites in Calaveras County, about 60 miles south of Sacramento, that yielded the finds Thursday and Friday, authorities have also been digging up an old cattle ranch well in San Joaquin County. Shermantine claims Herzog buried as many as 10 bodies in the well.

Herzog committed suicide last month after Sacramento bounty hunter Leonard Padilla told him Shermantine was disclosing the location of the well along with the two locations near his family’s former property.

Padilla has promised to pay Shermantine as much as $33,000 to disclose the locations of the bodies. Padilla said he hopes to collect on rewards being offered by the state of California for information about several missing persons suspected of being victims of Herzog and Shermantine.

Shermantine was convicted of four murders and sentenced to death. Herzog was convicted of three murders and sentenced to 77 years to life in prison. Herzog’s sentences was reduced to 14 years after an appeals court tossed his first-degree murder convictions after ruling his confession was illegally obtained.

Herzog was paroled in 2010 to a trailer outside the High Desert State Prison in Susanville. He committed suicide last month outside that trailer.

(Copyright 2012 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

  • tn

    What went around is finally coming around. Glad for the family’s closure, sad that these criminals did what they did. Question: What does the death-row convict get (money-wise) as agreed with the bounty hunter, and how will he claim in on his 2012 taxes? Do we the taxpayers end up being taxed so that the convict’s taxes are done? No wonder the state is in the state it is…

    • Ms Justice

      I totally agree with above comment… Any monetary awards to any involved names mentioned should be illegal. They should be paying to the families they destroyed for the next 40 years!!!… and because said “bounty hunter- PADILLA” released private info to person needing to be locked up/ and sentenced to excruciating death, sicko was able to take the easy way out !!!
      I call BS and non of the offenders or bounty hunters get anything since they all seem to play dirty! Its no wonder our country has such serious crime issues. if it was like other countries in the mid east, and they just immediately chopped off something like arms. legs, etc. I don’t think their would be such a high crime rate in the US!

      • Dena

        The bounty hunter got the victim’s family their loved ones bodies back. They now know what happened to them instead of being sucked into that black hole of always wondering. The bounty hunter probably mentioned it to Herzog in hopes that he too would give up information.

  • http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2012/02/13/rain-delays-search-for-bodies-in-speed-freak-killers-case/ Rain Delays Search For Bodies In ‘Speed Freak Killers’ Case « CBS San Francisco

    […] (CBS SF) – Authorities have found more bones and other evidence in a well at a rural Northern California ranch, though forced an end to Monday’s […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live