Oakland Gospel Choir Draws Nuisance Complaint, Faces $500 A Day Fine

by John Ramos

OAKLAND (KPIX 5) – Those who love Gospel music refer to it as “joyful noise” and it is anything but quiet.

“The music of the church reveals the life of the church, the enthusiasm of the church,” said Michael Wright, pastor at Solid Rock Baptist Church.

But the City of Oakland has a different description of it, they’re calling it a “nuisance.” Pleasant Grove Baptist Church in West Oakland recently received a letter from the city threatening a $3,500 nuisance fee and a $500 a day fine unless it toned down its choir practice.

The letter states in part, “…this activity may constitute a public nuisance due to its impact to the use and quiet enjoyment of the surrounding community’s property.”

ALSO READ: Driveway Hits San Francisco Real Estate Market With $50K Asking Price

“Kind of hard to believe because we’ve been here about 65 years in the community and all of a sudden we get some concerns about the noise,” said Thomas A Harris III, the pastor at Pleasant Grove.

Church pastors who met Wednesday said the real issue is gentrification. The church sits in a neighborhood full of old Victorians being snapped up by affluent tech workers.

“We’re being bought out. We’re being moved out. We are being priced out of our own neighborhood,” said Lawrence Van Hook, the senior pastor at Community Church.

They believe the complaints about the church’s music are coming from people new to the neighborhood.

“Those persons who are just new arrivals should not come and try to change the culture that existed before they arrived here,” said George Holland, president of the Oakland branch of the NAACP. “We cannot have people come attack churches about music.”

The NAACP is also demanding more specifics from the city and criticizing its handling of the issue.

“There should have been discussions between the community and those people who are saying the church is making too much noise,” Holland said.

At a meeting Wednesday night, the Oakland Creative Neighborhoods Coalition addressed the complaint. Coalition leaders said they are working with City Council president Lynette Gibson McElhaney to protect Oakland’s churches.

ALSO READ: Newsom Proposes California Gun Control Ballot Initiative In Wake Of School Shootings

The pastors said all churches are threatened by the city’s action and they plan to fight it. Pastors are also thinking about organizing outdoor services throughout Oakland so everyone can enjoy the joyful noise that much more.

For its part, the church said it will continue with choir practice on Thursday.

Comments

One Comment

  1. Susan Rocha says:

    Churches can be as loud as they want within their 4 WALLS! They have no right to intrude into other people’s homes!

  2. Susan Rocha says:

    I just went though 3 months of pure hell. The Los Angeles City Attorney, Divine Saviour Catholic Church and a 2 church members had me prosecuted. There was no evidence at all. The claims were all lies. Claiming I ran into the church yelling but there were no witnesses. Lies. 100 people there yet no one saw me. Lies. The Los Angeles City Attorney has time to prosecute with no evidence to shut one person up that takes on the Catholic Church due to their noise. Yet, refuses to prosecute in real criminal cases. The Los Angeles City Attorney has nothing to do but to be politically correct and take the side of the powerful (The Catholic Church) to silence the weak, one person with a voice. (Me).

    How low can the Los Angeles City Prosecutor and Divine Saviour Catholic Church go to shut me up? Very low. When they go low, I go high. I fought back. I did not accept their plea deal to shut me up. That was more than just mean and cruel. Pressing chumped up charges with absolutely NO evidence is cruel. I was fortunate enough to have a young, highly intelligent attorney, public defender Mr. Christopher Kim fight hard for me. He worked very hard on my behalf. He was so fantastic. I was truly fortunate to have had him represent me. I now have a new view on the public defender’s office. I saw how hard they work for their clients.

    The jury came back with a quick verdict within 30 minutes. Susan Rocha – Not Guilty on all counts

    Big bullies should never win.

    Please publish my story. First amendment is first amendment! LA City Attorney or Divine Saviour Catholic Church should NOT be allowed to silence me!! And, they won’t. They lost, I won! First amendment won!!

    Shame on those that do NOT support first amendment.
    Big bullies don’t win. Divine Saviour didn’t.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS San Francisco

Get The New CBS SF Bay Area Local App
Got Our Weather App?
Listen to Radio.com Anywhere, Anytime!

Watch & Listen LIVE