DUBLIN (CBS 5) – U.S. News and World Report recently released its list of the best high schools in the country, with Dublin High School topping the Bay Area at number 12. As it turns out, the celebration at the East Bay school was short lived.

Dublin High School Prinicpal Carol Shimizu saw her school’s ranking first online. 12th was by far the highest the campus had ever been ranked nationally.

READ MORE: 'Why Would Something Like This Happen To Me?' 94-Year-Old Anh 'Peng' Taylor Recovering After Shocking SF Stabbing Attack

“I was thrilled because I always believed that Dublin high was number one,” said Shimizu, who was ready to celebrate until she took a closer look at the data. “What is not accurate is that it says we have 493 students.”

The school actually has about 1,650 students. The district said the numbers must have been screwed up when records were converted to a new data system.

“We discovered that the magazine very likely used some enrollment numbers that were not accurate,” said Steve Hanke.

READ MORE: House Votes To Repeal Of 2002 Iraq War Authorization, Long Championed By Oakland Rep. Barbara Lee

The numbers likely skewed the results, which is a big disappointment for a school where 98 percent of the students graduate, and state test scores have been rising for the last five years.

Despite the disappointment, students and faculty said they know the school is doing well continuing to improve the learning environment.

See the full rankings.

MORE NEWS: 'Landmark Victory;' Bay Area Lawmakers React to Obamacare Decision By U.S. Supreme Court Decision

(Copyright 2012 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)