SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — YouTube said Thursday it will turn off comments on nearly all videos featuring kids — potentially affecting millions of posts on the site — after reports last week that pedophiles were leaving inappropriate comments on innocuous videos of children.

The change comes as YouTube grapples with moderating content across its platform as concerns about hate speech, violence and conspiracy theories continue to plague it.

It will take YouTube several months to disable comments on all videos featuring minors, the company said. It already started the process last week when it turned off comments from tens of millions of videos.

Advertisers including Nestle, AT&T and Fortnite-maker Epic Games pulled ads from YouTube last week after the inappropriate comments about children were unearthed by a popular YouTuber and media reports. At least one company, Nestle, was satisfied with YouTube’s response and reinstated ads late last week.

A small number of channels which have videos featuring kids will be allowed to keep comments turned on. But they must be known to YouTube and must actively monitor the comments beyond the standard monitoring tools YouTube provides.

Turning off comments on such a large number of videos seems an “extreme reaction,” said eMarketer analyst Paul Verna. But the issue involves the safety of children, so it makes sense YouTube would want to act quickly, he said.

Comments aren’t the main focus of the video-publishing site, but turning them off will likely diminish the experience for many users and video creators, he said.

YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki acknowledged the concerns Thursday, tweeting, “Nothing is more important to us than ensuring the safety of young people on the platform.”

The company said it has also released an updated version of its automated moderating system that it expects will identify and delete two times as many inappropriate comments.

YouTube, like Facebook, Twitter and other sites that allow user publishing, have faced increasing calls to monitor what appears on their sites and get rid of unsuitable content. The companies all say they have taken action to protect users. But issues keep popping up.

Concerns about YouTube comments weren’t even a top priority for advertisers and viewers a couple weeks ago, Verna said.

“It just makes you wonder, what’s the next thing that going to happen?”

© Copyright 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Comments (4)
  1. Chuck Lantz says:

    Not allowing comments at all is the lazy solution. The only way to keep comments “safe” is to monitor them before they are published. Many sites with comments sections do this regularly. It’s time consuming for the site publisher, and it’s less desirable for those writing the comments, but there is no other simple solution. Allowing comments on potentially harmful sites without moderation is asking for trouble.

  2. Emilio Aymat says:

    Well I DO think those sicko, pedos should be permanently banned from YouTube, but at the same time I don’t think it’s right that YouTube censor everything like Facebook does because what is a “conspiracy theory” or “violent” are subjective terms. Those old Tom & Jerry cartoons could definitely be considered “violent” by the excessively moral…so would they ban that too? And is anything that is critical of the status quo considered a “conspiracy theory”?

    1. Chuck Lantz says:

      While we may think that such bans or censorship are not right, the fact is that sites such as Facebook and YouTube in no way belong to us. They are owned and controlled by others, and that includes the comments.

      While there are laws, both criminal and civil, that can be enforced regarding the content of comments, there are no laws requiring that sites allow comments or not. or that require them to publish all comments intact. We’re all just “users”, and essentially guests, nothing more.