California, Maryland Suspend ‘Scared Straight’ Programs

SACRAMENTO (CBS / AP) — California and Maryland prison officials said Friday they have suspended youthful offender diversion programs featured on the television show “Beyond Scared Straight” after the U.S. Justice Department warned they could lose federal funding.

A prison agency spokesman in South Carolina, the only other state featured on the A&E Network series, said the diversion program there will be reviewed by the state’s incoming corrections chief.

The A&E series, which started Jan. 13, is produced by Arnold Shapiro, maker of the Emmy- and Oscar-winning 1979 television special, “Scared Straight.” Like that show, it documents visits by troubled teenagers to prisons where intimidating inmates deliver in-your-face lectures about the harshness of life behind bars.

The Justice Department said a study of nine such programs concluded they don’t deter teenagers from offending. In fact, the youths were more likely to offend in the future, according to Assistant Attorney General Laurie O. Robinson and Jeff Slowikowski, acting administrator of the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

“In light of this evidence, the U.S. Department of Justice discourages the funding of scared straight-type programs. States that operate such programs could have their federal funding reduced if shown not to have complied with the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act,” the federal officials wrote in an op-ed piece published Monday in The (Baltimore) Sun.

Slowikowski said Friday that his office recently expressed these concerns to the state offices in California, Maryland and South Carolina that administer his agency’s funds

The Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services suspended its diversion programs for review Jan. 25, spokesman Rick Binetti said. He said Corrections Commissioner J. Michael Stouffer ordered the review after learning that A&E was taping episodes on three different programs at three Maryland prisons.

“His decision to review and suspend was based on making sure in the future these programs have educational benefits to the youth involved,” Binetti said.

The suspension was reported Thursday by The (Hagerstown) Herald-Mail. Binetti said it was prompted by Stouffer’s desire to make sure all his Maryland diversion programs follow state policies.

The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation suspended its diversion programs Jan. 11 to ensure that they comply with the federal law, spokeswoman Terry Thornton said.

A&E Network spokesman Dan Silberman declined to comment on the suspensions or the Justice Department’s actions.

“We just document what these programs do,” he said.

The first episode of “Beyond Scared Straight” was shot nearly two years ago at the Maryland Correctional Institution at Jessup. It included a scene of two inmates appearing to throw an 18-year-old visitor into a utility room to demonstrate how easily inmates can be attacked by other prisoners out of the view of guards.

Binetti said the scene was planned and staged.

“What the cameras don’t show is, along with the inmates are correctional officers and the youth counselors right there in the hallway with full view of any interactions with inmates,” he said.

(© 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • CBS 5 Headlines For Friday, February 04, 2011 « Ben's Weblog

    […] California, Maryland Suspend ‘Scared Straight’ Programs […]

  • annfranklin

    Unbelievable! I was hoping this would help some of the stupid idiot teenagers in Harford County Maryland who think they are all knowing and nothing is ever going to touch them because their parents are always covering for them!

    • TJ

      I can’t believe they have cut the funding for this program. I thought that this was a great show of real life experiences. I have sat down with my own daughter who is commiting some of the same acts as some of the teens on the program. It has been a real eye opener for her as well as myself. There should be more programs for our troubled youth or this nation will be in trouble……. There is nothing like hands on or real life experiences

  • Mad momma

    I believe that they are good programs and was looking forward in taking a large group of troubled youth to the squiries program. If these programs are tooken away
    how does the attorney general suggest us to deal with the troubled youth. If nothing is done with the youth things may become really bad I think if they are cutting funding take it from some place else and leave programs like these alone.
    mad momma

    • Tielur Highknee

      Scared Straight has been proven in multiple studies to be a failure. In fact, it has been noted to increase recedivism on the notion of Tannenbaum’s (1983) theory of ‘labeling.” Why would we keep throwing tax money into a failing system? Your belief that they are “good programs” is not supported by any evidence, nor do you have any crediability for your opinion. That being said, I do agree with you that diversion programs are important to fund, but why not a program that has been proven to work (via cognitive-behaviorial theory, behavior modification, family-based therapy)? You are essentially trying to solve a complex issue with a rather simplistic solution. Juvenile crime committed is usually not a “black and white” issue so the solution is rarely “black and white” too. People usually do not just commit crimes to commit them, one must look at social and environmental issues as well. You are not going to scare a teen with criminals if their environment surrounds them with criminals. You are not going to scare a teen if they have a mental disability. You are not going to scare a teen if they are committing crimes while high on a drug. You are simply not going to scare a teen, period. Why not HELP them with the underlying issue, instead of attempting to SCARE them?

  • http://rel='nofollow' Nella Millbrand

    I got what you intend, saved to favorites , quite decent internet site .

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live