San Francisco Sit-Lie Ordinance Ineffective, Police Brass Told

SAN FRANCISCO (CBS SF) – San Francisco’s controversial sit-lie ordinance has been mostly ineffective in preventing transients from loitering in the city’s Haight-Ashbury neighborhood, a police lieutenant said at a department meeting Wednesday.

The ordinance, approved as Proposition L by 54 percent of voters in November, makes it illegal to sit or lie on public sidewalks between 7 a.m. and 11 p.m., with some exceptions.

The ballot measure was pushed by local business owners—many in the Haight-Ashbury—who complained that people walking by their shops were getting harassed by aggressive street youth.

Homeless advocates had argued that the law represents a loss of civil liberties and an attack on all homeless people.

After months of training, officers began enforcing the law in March, but at a bimonthly CompStat meeting involving some of the Police Department’s top brass Wednesday, police Lt. Belinda Kerr from the Park Station acknowledged that the law has not done much to change behavior in the area.

There has been “a prolific amount of arrests, citations and warnings … but I haven’t seen that it’s done a whole lot,” Kerr said.

She said the transients will often get up when they see officers drive by in their patrol cars, but “unfortunately are getting up and going around the block and then sitting down again.”

Kerr said the city is preparing for the summer months when “we get a big push of transients” by working with the district attorney’s office to develop stay-away orders for multiple offenders that would prevent them from being in the area.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Wire services may have contributed to this report.)

  • Adam

    I have found that Haight Street has become much nicer over the past few months. I live on Ashbury Street and I have not been verbally harassed on Haight since this law passed. Prior to the law passing it was not uncommon to be yelled at weekly if you didn’t give someone change.

  • Bloodhounds

    I wonder how long they will enforce it? I haven’t been to the Haight lately.

  • Chris Holloway

    Here’s an idea SFPD. Maybe don’t announce yourselves in a marked police car. Have you never heard of plainclothes officers?

  • RealityCheck

    Keep hammering away and making life unpleasant for the bums and eventually they will go somewhere nicer, like Berkeley.

  • Closer Look: San Francisco Sit-Lie Law Effective? « CBS San Francisco

    […] in March, after it was passed by voters in the November elections. At a recent public SFPD meeting, a Park Station lieutenant questioned the effectiveness of the law, saying she hasn’t “seen that it has done a whole […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live