Disturbing Garrido Videos Released As Dugard Book Hits Stores
EL DORADO COUNTY (CBS SF) – On the same day kidnapping survivor Jaycee Dugard’s memoir was released, new court documents and videos in connection with her disappearance were released Tuesday.
El Dorado County District Attorney Vern Pierson released the items, with Dugard’s consent, as her book “A Stolen Life” hit bookshelves.
The DA released several videos made by Phillip and Nancy Garrido, a map of Phillip’s Garrido’s South Lake Tahoe victims, a note written by Phillip Garrido and several pages of documents relating to Phillip Garrido’s earlier crimes.
Pierson said released the information to “highlight the gravity and severity of the mistakes made, and in hopes of improving the supervision and detection of sexual predators.”
According to a map of Garrido’s crimes, four of his previous victims had also been attacked in South Lake Tahoe.
The first known assault was a rape and kidnapping in Antioch on April 14, 1972.
That attack was followed by another rape and kidnapping on June 7, 1976, in South Lake Tahoe.
The next assault was on November 22, 1976, when Garrido attempted to rape and kidnap one woman and then raped and kidnapped a second woman, also in South Lake Tahoe.
That attack led to his conviction in federal court for kidnapping and in state court for rape. He was sentenced to 50 years in federal prison and five years to life in state prison.
He only served 11 years of that sentence, however, and was paroled in 1988.
On June 10, 1991, Garrido and his wife, Nancy Garrido, used a stun gun and forcibly kidnapped Dugard, then 11, as she walked to the school bus stop near her South Lake Tahoe home.
The couple took her to their home on Walnut Avenue just outside Antioch, where they held her captive for the next 18 years.
During that time, Garrido repeatedly raped Dugard and she gave birth to two daughters fathered by him.
She wasn’t found until Aug. 4, 2009, despite numerous searches by state and federal parole agents.
Phillip and Nancy Garrido have since pleaded guilty to rape and kidnapping charges. They were sentenced in June to life in prison.
A statement released Tuesday by Pierson said that law enforcement investigators knew that Garrido had committed the previous assaults at the time that they were searching for Dugard, but somehow Garrido never became a suspect.
Pierson, along with Sen. Ted Gaines, R-Roseville, law enforcement leaders and victims’ rights organizations plan to discuss some of the unanswered questions in the case at a public meeting in Sacramento on Aug. 3.
Among those questions are how Garrido, a repeat kidnapper and rapist with a history of kidnapping and raping women and girls in the Lake Tahoe area, and who was a registered sex offender on federal parole, avoided becoming a suspect in Dugard’s abduction.
The group also plans to discuss how Garrido managed to keep Dugard hidden in his backyard for 18 years while he was on federal and state parole.
The meeting will be part of a joint effort by Pierson and Gaines to examine what went wrong in Dugard’s case and create new legislation and reforms to prevent those mistakes from being repeated.
The hearing will include analysis of the many shortcomings in federal and state parole supervision and shortcomings in the initial law enforcement investigation of the case.
In a report on the federal parole supervision of Garrido that was released Thursday, the Administrative Office of the United States Courts describes numerous failures by federal parole agents to adequately supervise Garrido.
According to the report, federal parole officers handled Garrido’s case for more than 10 years and, despite having classified him as “high risk,” they only visited his house 10 or 11 times.
In the three years after Dugard was kidnapped, Garrido’s parole officer only made one attempt to contact Garrido at his home, but Garrido cut the visit short, claiming he had to drive his wife to work. After that, all contact for the next three years took place at the probation office, the report states.
Garrido was only found to be in violation of his parole once, despite multiple drug tests showing that he was using methamphetamine, according to the report.
A report released in 2009 by California Inspector General David Shaw also found that after reviewing the state’s parole supervision of Garrido, state parole agents missed numerous opportunities to discover Dugard living in his backyard.
According to Pierson, state parole officers visited Garrido’s home 60 times over a 10-year period and failed to discover Dugard. They also failed to investigate clearly visible utility wires running from Garrido’s house to the backyard compound where Dugard was being held captive.
A video released Tuesday by Pierson shows a state parole agent searching Garrido’s house sometime between 2000 and 2007. During the brief search, which appears to have been taped by Nancy Garrido, the parole officer briefly glances into each room, but never goes in the backyard.
“If the system had worked the way it should have, Ms. Dugard and her two daughters would have been discovered merely 30 feet away,” Gaines said in a statement released Monday.
Another video released by Pierson’s office appears to have also been taken by Nancy Garrido. In the video she is pretending to tape Garrido while he plays guitar in a park, but is actually recording young children in a playground behind him.
Pierson’s office also released a psychological evaluation of Garrido that led to his parole being granted in 1988.
The clinical psychologist who examined him described him as “a young man of average intelligence” who had “deeply held religious and philosophical convictions”.
The report went on to say that that the likelihood that Garrido would re-offend was minimal and recommended him for parole.
The psychologist did, however, write that if Garrido were to regress back to criminal behavior, he would most likely signal it by starting to use drugs again.
In a letter Garrido wrote to the parole board, he claimed that drug use caused him to lose his “reasoning power.”
“Seven years of using made me fall from reality,” Garrido wrote to the parole board.
According to the report on Garrido’s federal parole supervision, his parole officer largely ignored his positive drug tests.
Information about the Aug. 3 meeting can be found at www.senate.ca.gov/gaines.
Evidence From DA. (Quicktime required to view videos):
Video 1 (31.2 MB)
Video 2 (113 MB)
Video 3 (84.5 MB)
Map of Phillip Garrido’s South Lake Tahoe Victims
Chronological Record of Phillip Garrido’s Supervision 1988-1991
Phillip Garrido’s Certificate of Parole
Note Written By Phillip Garrido to Judge
Note Written By Jaycee When Police Asked Her Name
Phillip Garrido’s Original Mugshot
(Copyright 2011 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)