Experts Question Shooting Of Occupy Oakland Videographer

OAKLAND (CBS/AP) — An Oakland man said a police officer shot him with a rubber bullet or beanbag while he was videotaping last week’s standoff between law enforcement and a small group that took over a building and lit fires after a day of peaceful anti-Wall Street protests.

Experts in police use of force who reviewed the footage Scott Campbell captured said it appears the volley was unprovoked and inappropriate, the Oakland Tribune reported Tuesday.

In the video posted on YouTube, Campbell, 30, is heard calling, “Is this OK?” to a line of riot gear-clad officers. He told the newspaper that he was asking if his distance from them was adequate because an officer had asked him to step back. A firearm held by an officer then is seen going off, followed by Campbell’s yelps of pain.

The Oakland Police Department also has been criticized for wounding an Iraq War veteran during an Oct. 25 skirmish. City spokeswoman Karen Boyd said Tuesday that anyone who thinks they witnessed improper police conduct is encouraged to make a report with the police department’s Internal Affairs division or Oakland’s Civilian Police Review Board.

Officer Johanna Watson, a department spokeswoman, said Campbell’s allegations already are being looked into.

Related Coverage:
Inside The Occupy Oakland Encampment
Quan Says Occupy Oakland Hurting City, Wants Protesters To Negotiate

University of South Carolina criminal justice professor Geoffrey Alpert said that unless something occurred off-camera to provoke the officer, the shooting was “one of the most outrageous uses of a firearm” he’d ever seen.

“Unless there’s a threat that you can’t see in the video, that just looks like absolute punishment, which is the worst type of excessive force,” Alpert said.

Campbell, who identifies himself as an anarchist, said he took video of the confrontation that occurred early Nov. 3 because he wanted to document any instances of excessive force, but did not imagine that he would be a target.

Authorities have said they moved to arrest more than 100 people and used tear gas and beanbags after a small group of self-proclaimed anarchists entered a vacant building with bottles and flares and then lit fires in the street when officers tried to clear the building.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS SF. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

  • Tim Giangiobbe

    I was sick of tear gas and left to go to San Francisco just to arrive as BART was being shut at Embarcadero and the word on the street was over 300 cops staging in the Mission from neighboring agencies as fart as Fresno, Santa Clara,Sacramento , Monterrey and San Rafael all ready to kick hippie ass it sucks I am a baby boomer and peaceful and an Army Veteran that says the elite can stay above the fray for awhile and eventually we shall cross paths and You better hope We have been appeased

  • Quan Calls On Occupy Oakland Protesters To Negotiate « CBS San Francisco

    […] Coverage: Experts Question Shooting Of Occupy Oakland Filmer Occupy Oakland Protest […]

  • Tim Giangiobbe

    It’s time we stop listen what’s that sound everybody look what’s going down

    What a field day for the heat a thousand people in the street
    singing songs and carrying signs

  • WASPy

    Water Cannons

    Dillion Mini-Guns

    I could clear-out these squatters, looters and parasites, pronto.

  • Officer Who Fired Beanbag At Occupy Oakland Videographer Reassigned « CBS San Francisco

    […] Oakland police Capt. Ersie Joyner III said he could be fired or demoted because of the Nov. 3 beanbag incident. […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live