REDWOOD CITY (CBS SF) – For the second time, a jury has found a man guilty of murdering the daughter of Oakland Raider Hall of Fame wide receiver Fred Biletnikoff.

Mohammed Haroon Ali, 36, was convicted of first-degree murder in the strangling of ex-girlfriend Tracey Biletnikoff at a drug rehabilitation center in February of 1999.

Ali’s original 2001 conviction had been overturned in 2009 after an appellate court ruled prosecutors had improperly dismissed black jurors.

Biletnikoff’s family members wiped away tears and hugged each other after emerging from the Redwood City courtroom Thursday morning.

“To have to go through it again—it’s not a good situation, but the outcome is what we hoped for,” said Fred Biletnikoff, Jr., the victim’s brother.

Biletnikoff’s father told reporters that the family is proud of his daughter, who had been recovering from a drug addiction before her murder.

“She knew she had missed so much of her teenage life by getting involved in drugs, and she knew she was getting it back,” he said.

KCBS’ Margie Shafer Reports:

It was through drug treatment programs that Tracey Biletnikoff met Ali, and the pair eventually began dating.

On Feb. 15, 1999, the couple got into an argument after Ali told Biletnikoff he had relapsed and gone on a drug binge two days earlier.

He testified during the trial that he relapsed after learning that an ex-girlfriend was pregnant with a child he had fathered. He said the woman had rejected his attempts to contact her.

Ali testified that the day of the murder, Biletnikoff blocked the office door where they were fighting and tried to hit him.

His hands moved to her neck and he strangled her until she was unconscious, according to his testimony and prosecutors.

Wagstaffe said Ali then used a rolled-up T-shirt to strangle Biletnikoff again to ensure that she was dead.

The defendant dragged Biletnikoff’s body out of the office and into one of the rehab facility’s vans, which he drove to Canada College in Redwood City. Ali then dumped the body down a ravine, where it was found the next day, half-clothed, according to prosecutors.

Ali testified that he had tried to make Biletnikoff’s murder look like a sexual crime.

Ali fled to Mexico in Biletnikoff’s car but was arrested after trying to re-enter the United States on Feb. 16.

Wagstaffe told the jury during the trial that Ali intended to kill Biletnikoff and continued to strangle her even as she tried to fight him off.

During closing arguments on Monday, he also argued that the defendant showed intent to kill during the three to five minutes it took to choke Biletnikoff to death.

But defense attorney Peter Goldsheider argued throughout the trial that the killing was a spontaneous crime of passion, warranting the lesser charge of involuntary manslaughter.

He argued that Ali had not carefully considered the consequences, nor had he intended to kill Biletnikoff.

The defendant’s 2001 first-degree murder conviction earned him a 64-year prison sentence.

He now faces life in prison and is set to be sentenced on June 14.

(Copyright 2012 by CBS San Francisco. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)

Comments (5)
  1. Dave says:

    What a waste of time and tax money!

  2. MissCyanide says:

    Ummmm why did we waste money on sending this to trial again? not to mention the pain and anguish the family had to re-live again! this disgusts me,……

  3. norm says:

    Why was the original conviction overturned? Nould help if the reporter had done a better job reporting.

  4. Phobos Deimos says:

    Where’s the editor for this article? So the murder happened in February 1999, but then the article states:

    “On Feb. 15, 2009, the couple got into an argument after Ali told Biletnikoff he had relapsed and gone on a drug binge two days earlier.”

    So is this a retrial because Tracey Biletnikoff came back from the dead 10 years after her murder?

    Articles are poorly written nowadays.

  5. tn says:

    The writing standard of years past has gone. Today, many articles seem to be poorly written or unedited. This is what happens when you let go of the educated and experienced. Looks like the hiring tests need a lot of work or review.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Watch & Listen LIVE