kpix-7-2013-masthead kcbs 7-2013-masthead

Local

Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 Report

View Comments
Christin-Ayers_BIO-HEAD Christin Ayers
Christin Ayers is a general assignment reporter for KPIX 5 Eyewitness...
Read More

Get Breaking News First

Receive News, Politics, and Entertainment Headlines Each Morning.
Sign Up
Trending Stories On CBS SF

rand paul berkeley 479582893 Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 ReportStrange Bedfellows: Silicon Valley Techies ‘Like’ Conservative Senator Rand Paul

wawona packing co Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 ReportPeaches, Nectarines, Plums Recalled from Costco, Trader Joe’s After Listeria Bacteria Discovered

portrait fremont Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 Report$50,000 Painting Discovered Tucked Away In Fremont Museum Attic, Confirmed On PBS’s Antiques Roadshow

lawn spray painting Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 ReportSoCal Homeowners Spray-Painting Lawns Green To Avoid Water Fees During Drought

reckless motorcycle 050614 Lawsuit Filed Over Fracked Oil Trains In The Bay Area After KPIX 5 ReportDaredevil Motorcyclist Arrested In April For Illegal Stunts Wrecks Corvette In Oakland; 1 Dead

RICHMOND (KPIX 5) — Two weeks ago, KPIX 5 discovered trains carrying explosive fracked crude oil have been rolling into the Bay Area under everyone’s radar. On Thursday, four environmental groups have filed a lawsuit over it, calling the crude by rail terminal illegal.

Earthjustice attorney Suma Peesapati had no idea the long trains were coming into the Bay Area until she saw KPIX 5’s story.

“I was flabbergasted,” Peesapati said. “This just happened under the cover of night.”

Read More:
Read The Legal Complaint (.pdf)
Read Request For Preliminary Injunction (.pdf)
Trains Carrying Fracked Oil Spotted In Bay Area
California May Not Be Prepared For Disasters Involving Fracked Oil Trains
Explosion Survivor Warns Of Fracked Oil Trains

Fracked crude oil from the Bakken shale fields of North Dakota can result in deadly explosions in a derailment. Yet we discovered the energy company Kinder Morgan started bringing 100-car trains loaded with the oil right into the heart of Richmond six months ago, all without having to go through any environmental review.

“We can’t hold up their permit because there is public opposition. As long as somebody doesn’t increase their emissions, we give them a permit,” Jim Karas of the Bay Area Air Quality Management District told KPIX 5.

Karas said since the rail yard was previously unloading ethanol trains, switching to fracked crude oil was no big deal. “Very small deal, very well controlled, very few emissions,” he said.

According to permit documents obtained by KPIX 5, Kinder Morgan claimed the operation “will not increase emissions beyond currently permitted levels”, and requested that the air district treat it “as an alteration, not a modification”.

“This hardly a minor alteration. I mean this fundamentally changes the nature of the operation and the environmental impacts,” said Peesapati.

Earthjustice filed a lawsuit on behalf of 4 environmental groups: Communities for a Better Environment, Asian Pacific Environmental Network, the Sierra Club, and the Natural Resources Defense Council.

The complaint claims the Air District’s “clandestine approval” of the project “ignores the well-known and potentially catastrophic risk to public health and safety.”

“These trains are rolling and they pose an immediate threat to the local community,” said Peesapati.

“It’s really a slap in the face against the people of Richmond,” said Andres Soto with Communities for a Better Environment. He hopes the courts will take action quickly. And not just because of the danger of explosions.

“There’s a number of chemicals that are constituents in this crude oil that are carcinogenic,” he said.

Adding to the risk, Soto said the tanker trucks that deliver the crude to local refineries. “It’s going to take three trucks to unload one train car and that is an extreme expansion of the number of trips by diesel trucks on our city streets and on our state highways.”

KPIX 5 reached out to Kinder Morgan and the Air District Thursday night. Both said they don’t comment on pending litigation. The lawsuit calls on the Air District to pull Kinder Morgan’s permit, and asks the judge to issue an injunction that would shut down the terminal until a full environmental impact report is completed.

View Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus