OAKLAND (KPIX 5) — A proposal to ban Oakland’s use of facial recognition technology passed its first administrative hurdle late Thursday, but has a long road ahead before it becomes a law.
The city’s Privacy Commission unanimously approved the ban which now has to pass through the Public Safety Committee and the Oakland City Council before being adopted.READ MORE: COVID: San Francisco Businesses Thriving Again Under New Yellow Tier Freedoms
If passed, the ban would strictly prevent the city from using the technology, but private companies would remain free to use it. San Francisco is currently considering a similar ban.
Brian Hofer, chair of the Oakland Privacy Commission said the San Francisco District Attorney’s office and the Alameda County Sheriff’s Department have already reported using the technology to fight crime.
“We need to limit it now,” said Hofer. “We’re moving to amend the [Oakland Privacy Ordinance] to prohibit the use of facial recognition technology because of the dangers it possesses.”
The risks of Amazon’s facial recognition technology, Rekognition, were highlighted last year when the ACLU tested the software and found that it falsely matched 28 members of Congress with mugshots. In a statement, the ACLU said, “The false matches were disproportionately of people of color, including six members of the Congressional Black Caucus.”READ MORE: Early Season Red Flag Warning Sends Residents Scrambling To Protect Homes
“We know that it has a really high error rate, especially for women and people of color,” Hofer said. “The darker your skin is, the more trouble it has identifying you.”
People KPIX 5 spoke to in Oakland feared that the technology would not just make mistakes, but it would also take away a person’s anonymity.
“Anytime they run your face through the software I’m sure it’s going to log your address, the time and everything else so it’s kind of just keeping tabs on everybody,” said Richard Hogan, a supporter of the proposed ban.
But Christina Perkins said facial recognition technology might be the crime-fighting tool that law enforcement needs.MORE NEWS: Former KPIX 5 Anchor Dana King's Sculpture Selected For Golden Gate Park African-American Memorial
“I think it’s necessary though in order to keep the crime rate down and to keep our neighborhood, our environments protected,” she said. “It definitely could be a good tool.”