Giants’ Posey Suffers Broken Leg, Torn Ligaments, Possibly Out For Year

SAN FRANCISCO (CBS Sports / AP) — Buster Posey has fractured a bone in his lower left leg and could be out for the season, delivering a potentially devastating blow to the San Francisco Giants.

Related Stories:

>>Giants Shut Out As Marlins Complete Sweep

>> Posey Hurt In Extra Innings Loss

>> Daily Madden: Posey Injury Ignites Rule Change Debate

>> KCBS Sports Fans: Enough’s Enough With Homeplate Collisions

The Giants announced Thursday that Posey was on the disabled list with a broken fibula, a day after he was crushed by Florida’s Scott Cousins in a homeplate collision while trying to block the winning run in the 12th inning against the Marlins.

After Thursday afternoon’s 1-0 loss to the Marlins, Giants head trainer Dave Groeschner said that an MRI revealed torn ligaments in the ankle, in addition to the broken fibula.

“We think the fracture is going to be fine, the ankle injury is most concerning to us.” said Groeschner, who indicated that the surgery needed for the ligaments is a greater concern. “Obviously he is going to be out for a while.”

Groeschner said a second MRI was performed on the catcher’s knee, but no damage was found.

“We’ve seen this stuff before. We’ve had other guys through our system, catchers included, that have returned no problem,” Groeschner said without giving a timetable on Posey’s return. “This is probably more of a football-type injury, a contact injury, and those guys come back.”

The team expects Posey to have the surgery to repair the ligaments on both sides of his ankles within a week; doctors may have to insert a screw into his ankle to help set the bone.

Posey has been San Francisco’s best cleanup hitter this season, a team leader in the clubhouse and key cog behind the plate for one of the best rotations in baseball. He was batting .284 with four home runs and 21 RBIs, just finding his groove in the midst of a 13-game hitting streak.

His loss will be an enormous obstacle for the Giants to overcome if they want to repeat as champs. Backup Eli Whiteside will be Posey’s immediate replacement.

The Giants later announced that Chris Stewart had been recalled to take Posey’s place, with Brandon Belt also joining the roster along with Brandon Crawford.

KCBS’ Doug Sovern Reports:

Posey’s broken leg could heal in one-to-two months, a time span common for a broken leg. However, broken legs can mean a wide range of severity, and the complication of torn ligaments makes a possible ETA for a return that much more murky. Some players return from a broken leg inside two months. Others miss almost two full seasons, as Kendrys Morales of the Angels can attest. It would surprise no one if Posey was done for the season, including teammate Pablo Sandoval.

“I feel so bad because we lost Buster for rest of the season it’s gonna be hard with out him,” Sandoval tweeted on Thursday.

Posey’s agent, Jeff Berry, said he was planning on calling Joe Torre, the new leader of on-field operations, in the hopes of changing the rules that allow runners to barrel into catchers.

“You leave players way too vulnerable,” Berry said. “I can tell you Major League Baseball is less than it was before [Posey’s injury]. It’s stupid. I don’t know if this ends up leading to a rule change, but it should. The guy [at the plate] is too exposed.

“If you go helmet to helmet in the NFL, it’s a $100,000 fine, but in baseball, you have a situation in which runners are [slamming into] fielders. It’s brutal. It’s borderline shocking. It just stinks for baseball. I’m going to call Major League Baseball and put this on the radar. Because it’s just wrong.”

“It’s part of baseball. I understand that,” Giants manager Bruce Bochy said in a news conference on Thursday. “Guys run into catchers. Being a catcher, I’ve been in a few of them. You’re in harm’s way there. I do think we need to consider changing the rules a little bit because the catcher’s so vulnerable — and there are so many who’ve gotten hurt, and just a little bit. I mean, they’ve had their careers or shortened. And here’s a guy that’s very popular in baseball. Fans want to see him play. Now, he’s out for a while. I’d like to see maybe something considered here where we can protect these guys a little bit more. They just don’t have the protection to take a guy coming in full speed, with that kind of force.”

Bochy said he had previously spoken to Posey about not getting out in front and blocking the plate — and to an extent, Posey tried to honor that.

“He was not completely in front of the plate. He was in a position where he could make a tag without being hit, too,” Bochy said. “He just got himself in a tough position there because [the way] his leg was situated. He was down on one knee, and ideally, you’d like to have the foot pointed that way to protect you a little bit. But, again, you’re trying to handle a throw. You don’t have time to get set up perfectly. That’s what hurt him was his leg was tucked underneath him when he got hit.”

This is a sticky situation. On one hand, Bochy clearly feels that Cousins didn’t need to take out Posey. On the other, it was a game in extra innings with a potential scoring play. Cousins and the ball both arrived to Posey at virtually the same time, and if Cousins had chosen to attempt to slide to the plate, there’s no guarantee he would have made it. It’s just an unfortunate end result, but that’s baseball.

Cousins tried to reach out to Posey, leaving two voicemails and told reporters Thursday that he did not sleep Wednesday night. “The last thing I wanted to do was break the guy’s leg,” he said.

Cousins, who went to the University San Francisco, lives in the Bay Area and had almost a dozen friends and family in attendance, apologized repeatedly for injuring Posey. But he believes — as most Giants also reiterated — that he made a clean baseball play.

“I’m not trying to end anybody’s season or anything like that. I just was trying to play hard and score the go-ahead run,” Cousins said.

Belt takes the place of outfielder and pinch-runner Darren Ford, who hit the DL with an ankle sprain. The Giants were originally going to resist calling Belt up to replace Ford, but the loss of Posey has changed matters as the Giants need to find a way to inject offense into the club, and fast. The Giants won’t have any trouble fitting Belt into the lineup, as first baseman Aubrey Huff is struggling with the bat while left field can also accommodate Belt’s production.

Even though Huff hasn’t played third base since a 33-game stint in 2008, it’s possible the Giants could slide him to third temporarily to get Belt’s bat in at first base, which would allow the team to continue playing Pat Burrell and Nate Schierholz in the outfield. In this scenario, Miguel Tejada would move back to shortstop, a position he vacated to fill Pablo Sandoval’s absence at third. Now that the Giants have also lost Mike Fontenot to the DL due to a groin strain, the options to fill the shortstop position are weak enough to the point the club would likely benefit from Tejada moving back to short all in the name of getting Belt’s bat into the lineup.

Stewart has been with four different teams in the last five years, playing mostly at Triple-A. He received eight at-bats in 2006 for his career debut with the White Sox before collecting 43 plate appearances for the Rangers in ’07. The 29-year-old moved onto the Yankees, snagging just one game’s worth of playing time in ’08, playing for New York’s Triple-A team the entirety of 2009 before returning to the bigs with San Diego last season. At San Diego he appeared in two games as a defensive replacement. Now, Stewart could easily match his career 54 plate appearances as the new tandem in San Francisco. Eli Whiteside is expected to get the bulk of the playing time in the early going, but he doesn’t exactly command being slotted in the lineup every day.

Crawford, meanwhile, was playing at high-Class A, hitting .322/.412/.593 in 69 plate appearances. He spent the bulk of 2010 with Double-A, hitting .241/.337/.375 and started the 2011 season with a broken finger. The corresponding move for Crawford is not yet known, but it is likely Fontenot to the DL. He’ll be the infield backup, with Emmanuel Burriss likely slotting in at shortstop if they don’t move Tejada back to short.

Assuming Posey is out for a long time, if not the rest of the season, the Giants may want to call up ex-Giant Bengie Molina, who was with San Francisco from 2007 until partway through last season, when he was moved to the Rangers and faced the Giants in the World Series. Molina, a free agent, has been waiting for both the right fit and price before playing again. He may have just found it.

(Copyright 2011 by CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

More from Sovern Nation
  • Joe

    Judge for yourself, here’s a photo of what happened:

  • KCBS Sports Fans: Enough’s Enough With Homeplate Collisions « CBS San Francisco

    […] can really enjoy watching San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey have his season ended in a horrible home plate collision. It’s ugly, and the sight of Posey writhing in pain afterward is even […]

  • Lalo

    Sorry, But this was totally uncalled for. He had a total clear shot to home and probably would have been safe. WHAT THE F WAS HE THINKING.
    Now Posey is out for the season.

    • EN

      It wasn’t a cheap shot. Were you even watching the game? Many catchers have been runned over just as bad.

  • Jan Jones

    Looks like a malicious hit to me. If Cousins didn’t want to take Buster out, why did he run right into him?

    • corey

      cause thats how u play the game, youre suppose to take out the ball from the catcher…funny how only the “fans” are talking about it being dirty and not one baseball player


    No! heard lots of arguements but the fact is? “unless MLB changes the rules! it is perfectly legal to come in shoulders first! as opposed to slide in! if there a is line open or not! it ‘s up to who ever is kneeling down? to make there own calll! GET WELL SOON POSEY WE NEED U!!! GO GIANTS!

  • Tracy Metherell

    Bringing back Bengie Molina to catch is a no brainer. Sign him NOW!

  • chris williams

    the runner is not goiing to slide if the catcher is too far in front of the plate.,leaving no choice but to slam into the catcher.

  • Marlins Shut Out Posey-Less Giants To Complete Sweep « CBS San Francisco

    […] day after the star catcher sustained a broken lower left leg when Scott Cousins crashed into him at the plate—likely ending Posey’s season—the Marlins […]

  • Ray Darbyshire

    Cousins did not go for the plate, he went for the man. He says the last thing he wanted to do was break a guy’s leg. The last thing he did was touch the plate.
    What he did was within the rules but that doesn’t mean he isn’t a prime a-hole.

  • Sharon

    As far I am concerned this was a flagrant foul. In basketball he would have been thrown out and fined. The same should be true here. In football it is illegal. He purposely went into him to injure and he should admit it. There was absolutely reason to take Posey out like that. There should be severe punishment for sure!!! Absolutely no excuse, and I am not even a Giants fan.

    • EN

      As a catcher who has been slammed into, this was unfortunate for Buster. But, it wasn’t a cheap shot Sharon. The runner has every right when the catcher is blocking home plate.

      • Sue

        Posey wasn’t blocking home plate.

  • Eddy Merkx

    Buster is young, fit, and in the best of hands medically. He is a determined, focused, and has a great mental attitude. I am sure this will all help in making his recovery a fast and clean one! Take care, Buster, you rock!

  • Enrique Mora

    First of all let me say as a San Franciscan and a Giants fan that it is heartbreaking to see the play and ultimatley to hear the extent of the injury. With that said I believe that the trajedy that happened was not the fault of how Cody positioned himself nor how fast or at what angle Cousins was running. These types of plays are a bad part of baseball and have been for way too long. The guilty party here is MLB which has not chosen to really deal with this issue. My gut feeling is this incident will be the straw that broke the camels back. The fact that this happened to last years Rookie of The year and catcher on the 2010 Championship team will only add to the cuase of redoing the rules in regards to homplate challenges.

  • Ben

    It looks like Scott Cousins was trying to lay him out. He wasn’t even going for the plate. Posey was on one side of the plate and Cousins could of went around him but chose to take him out instead of going for the plate. Bad play on Cousins. Looks malicious to me.

  • Sue

    Watch the video again. Cousins lowers his shoulder goes for Posey, not the plate. In my opinion, it was a cheap shot and a totally inappropriate play.

  • Ken Riley

    Posey blocked the plate with a horrible catchers stance. Better positioning would have allowed him to better absorb the hit and not get stuck.
    The base runner has every right to the plate. Look at YouTube videos of Pete Rose (Reds) barreling head first into catchers. Jeff Kent (Giants) destroyed the careers of a few catchers crashing into catchers the same way. Where were the calls of dirty player back then?

    • EN

      Giants fans have tunnel vision, it’s ok when a Giant does the same thing

  • Posey Says His Season Is Likely Over « CBS San Francisco

    […] Florida Marlins’ Scott Cousins collides with San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey (28) during the 12th inning of a baseball game at AT&T Park in San Francisco, Wednesday, May 25, 2011. (AP) var addthis_product = 'wpp-257'; var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};SAN FRANCISCO (CBS / AP) — Giants catcher Buster Posey said it’s “highly likely” he will miss the rest of the season after injuring his left leg and ankle in a collision at home plate. […]

  • Giants’ Posey Suffers Broken Leg, Torn Ligaments, Possibly Out For Year | Inside Fantasy Football

    […] Giants’ Posey Suffers Broken Leg, Torn Ligaments, Possibly Out For Year Buster Posey has fractured a bone in his lower left leg and could be out for the season, delivering a potentially devastating blow to the San Francisco Giants. Read more on CBS San Francisco […]

  • Daily Madden: Giants GM Gets Personal On Posey Injury Comments « CBS San Francisco

    […] Related tags Brian Sabean, Daily Madden, Dallas Mavericks, Florida Marlins, John Madden, Miami Heat, San Francisco Giants, Scott Cousins var addthis_product = 'wpp-257'; var addthis_config = {"data_track_clickback":true};SAN FRANCISCO (KCBS) – San Francisco Giants General Manager Brian Sabean is calling for a rule change to prevent home plate collisions in the aftermath of the season-ending injury to Giants catcher Buster Posey. […]

  • Cousins Issues New Appology Over Posey Injury After Threats « CBS San Francisco

    […] collision at home plate during a game May 26 left Posey with a broken bone in his lower left leg and three torn ligaments in his ankle. He’s […]

  • MLB’s Torre To Speak To Angry Giants GM Sabean « CBS San Francisco

    […] No one who likes baseball should be happy that Buster Posey got hurt. […]

  • Return Of Posey Could Put Giants Back In Contention « CBS San Francisco

    […] long-awaited return from season-ending leg and ankle injuries suffered in a frightening home-plate collision last May 25 with the Marlins’ Scott Cousins is […]

  • MLB Adopts New Rule For Home Plate Collisions In Wake Of Posey Injury « CBS San Francisco

    […] FRANCISCO (CBS/AP) – Nearly three years after a violent home plate smash-up ended the season of star San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey, Major League Baseball is changing the rules for collisions at home […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Guide To The Holidays
Shine A Light On The Holiday Season With ‘Giving Tuesday’

Listen Live